People are smart and companies are STUPID! – That’s it… please allow me to illustrate:

 

I am working with some buyer clients; a great couple- first time buyers, great credit, motivated to get into their first home, etc… these people are EXACTLY who should be benefiting from the “Insert Expletive Here” market we are all struggling through.

 

We have been working together for a few weeks now and in the course of our searching, we come across a great place in Gilbert, listed at $165k. Looking at the listing sheet, I was thrilled to find out that this is not a lender owned property (as MANY are these days under $200k) but rather a corporate relocation. Being trained as a corporate relocation specialist, I am very comfortable that I will be dealing with a system with which I am very familiar.

 

In the course of our due diligence prior to submitting our offer, we find out there is already an offer in on the property. I don’t know what the offer is, but I have been told that it is a less than full price offer. My clients come to the decision that we will submit our offer in the “highest and best” manner and cross our fingers. Our offer is:

 

Purchase price – $165,000 w/ Seller contributing 3% ($4,950) to cover Buyers closing costs. NET TO SELLER: $160,050

 

We submit, and we wait. I get a call from the agent that the Seller (the homeowner’s employer) has countered. No biggie, it always happens, “So what is it?” I say. She tells me:

 

Purchase price – $155,000 w/ Seller contributing 0% to cover Buyer’s closing costs. NET TO SELLER: $155,000

 

Do me a favor at this point and take a look at the two scenarios I have put up here. Our offer has the Seller netting over $5,000 MORE than their counter offer. I ask the listing agent “Are you sure this is right?” She tells me it is and explains that the Seller has a contract with the homeowner / transferee that they will cover the mortgage but no “Non-Customary” costs, ie: the closing costs we asked for. Intrigued I say “Well, it’s interesting and I will take it to my clients”.

 

Sure enough, as great as the deal sounds, my Buyers just can’t do it. It is simply a cash issue. They recognize that they would make out better on paper with the Sellers offer, but it’s no good if they don’t have the cash. I go back to the listing agent and tell her our situation. She agrees to take it back to the Seller and “Go to bat” for my clients.

 

Next day I get a call from the listing agent- “They said NO”. Completely perplexed, I go back to my clients and tell them that we are back at square one- Time to start over.

 

I’m driving after this conversation and this whole thing is just not sitting right with me. So I call the agent back again and have a very friendly, but very pointed conversation with her. I explain to her that I am having a hard time explaining this to my clients, and I am realizing that it’s because it makes no sense to me. So I ask her to please clarify how this offer is being rejected.

 

The listing agent goes on to tell me (while sharing her frustration) that even though she knows our offer is better for the Seller, even though the homeowner knows it is better for the Seller and even though the Seller knows that the deal is better for them, the fact is that they have a contract with the homeowner and this contract says NO CLOSING COSTS.  “So their contract trumps logic?” I ask “Yes” I get back…. And that’s pretty much it.

 

So here are my thoughts- while the whole world is searching for the reason that our economy is in the crapper, why millions of Americans are being laid off, why Real estate values are soooo down, pretty much why things suck- I have it figured out. People are smart and companies are STUPID! Every person I spoke with about this scenario recognized that it made no sense but admitted that there was NO opportunity for Human Intervention. There is no one able to go above the almighty contract and make a decision that is better for the Buyer AND the Seller.

 

So besides just listening to me vent about this, please allow me to break down for you the result of this stupidity, and how it affects me, you and EVERYONE who reads this.

 

Because of this contract that could not be worked around, the other offer submitted on this property was accepted. This means that the Seller, a MULTI BILLION DOLLAR BIG NAME PHARMACUTECAL COMPANY (whos name starts with a “P”) has accepted an offer that is netting them approximately $20,000 less than our offer. What does that mean for you and everyone else? A few things:

 

- This home has gone been sold to an investor and is now at a greater risk of being abandoned should that investors financial situation take a turn for the worse. For Example, I don’t live there, so why should I stretch to keep paying for it.
- The $20,000 lower sales price means that this home will now become a lower sales comp for the entire neighborhood. This means that neighbors who sell for months to come will have their home valued lower because of this sale.
- The listing agent who worked diligently to perform her duty and bring her clients the highest and best offer possible will now make less money and have less money to spend since her compensation is a function of the sales price.
- The pharmaceutical company who was at the helm of this deal has now lost an additional $20,000 on this transaction. I hope this does not come as a surprise to anyone reading this, but losses like that do not get absorbed into the massive black hole that is big pharmaceuticals. This loss will be split up a teeny tiny bit across EVERYONE who relies on the drugs that this company manufactures in the form of higher drug costs meaning there are literally millions of people who will be affected by this transaction.

 

Now imagine this scenario playing out thousands of times a month. Thousands of decisions being made on policy and NOT on common sense. THIS IS THE PROBLEM PEOPLE!!! The world has lost its way by refusing to allow common sense to correct a problem that is heading things in the wrong direction. Now more than ever, it is the responsibility of every individual to apply common sense in their life and their career as well as demand it of those whom are make decisions for them. Get on it people! Of course, if you disagree, please feel free to let me know

 

Soapbox Out!